This month's GNU book was "When Everything Changed" by Gail Collins. I was the hostess.
Overall I think it was an excellent book for dicussion. We didn't end until 5:45 which is unusual!
The book is a series of essays about women in the early 1960s and later, when everything changed for women. I would say that the biggest change for me, as a white woman, was women in the workplace.
Now the idea that women have not worked outside the home is nuts. A woman's work is never done - so why is there is this myth that women working is something new?
In my opinion what happened was that after WWII many middle-class women could afford not to work. There were still plenty of working women but they were coldly relegated to low-paid jobs and treated poorly. These women were not who the media idolized in the post-war boom days. The media focused on women with husbands who had good jobs and could afford to raise a family on one income.
During the 60s and 70s things changed. The Civil Rights movement gave women some legal remedies for some of the injustices they'd suffered for years and stagflation pushed those middle-class women into the workplace to maintain living standards. While stagflation was something most could have lived without, the Civil Rights acts that gave women legal standing was important.
The book tells the tale of a woman in Georgia who worked for the phone company and was barred from a better job because it would require her to lift thirty pounds. The woman, working in an office, was currently required to hoist her more-than-thirty pound typewriter off her desk everyday. Yet she was barred from a better job by this restriction. The 'system' was happy to use the lifting restriction to protect those jobs from female applicants, and didn't care if she was hoisting that typewriter around.
The book also describes the glamorous job of the decade - airline stewardess. Young women of specific proportions were hired on to serve the mostly male executives who flew. The description rang a bell with me because one of my Aunts had been a stewardess on TWA. Her mother, my Grandmother, told us all about it. I don't know if it was really a glamorous job, but to my Grandmother -who grew up on a farm, married at 19 and worked for no pay all her life- it was and we often heard about my Aunt's adventures. Although being a stewardess wasn't a great job, it was far beyond anything my Grandmother had ever imagined and she viewed it as something quite exciting.
If you look closely at the photo you'll see that most of the young women have diamond rings on their fingers. The average Stewardess lasted 18 months and then she got married. She could not continue to work if she was married. My Aunt worked at TWA about 18 months, quit, went back to school and moved to California to take up the other acceptable career for women - teaching. Unlike most women she never married.
Reading "When Everything Changed" reminds me that the changes for women in the workplace were not really the main intention of the Civil Rights crusaders. The Civil Rights legislation was not really about ending rules that kept women in low-paid job, the words "sex" were added as an afterthought to procure a few votes from certain legislatures.
Unintended consquences is a phrase that we've all heard recently. The Texas Board of Education wants to 'educate' children about the unintended effects of various laws - as if these are all negative. I hope that they mention that women having legal remedies for un-fair work rules that served to save better paid jobs for men, could be considered an un-intended conquence of the Civil Rights legislation. Even back to the Bible women have worked. It is a happy un-intended consquence to know that they have leverage in the workplace to get better jobs and be judged on their abilities and preformance and not just their sex.
