The book, "Thinking Fast and Slow" by Daniel Kahneman, describes the human mind and it's thinking patterns. Excerpts have been popping up in the media for quite some time. This article was one of the best I've encountered and does far more justice to the book than I ever could: Don't Blink, the Hazards of Confidence. This particular article convinced me it would be worth the effort to read for myself.
I've found that reading books that have been heavily excerpted in the media, a search on this title will yield a list of links to articles citing it, is not always worthwhile. Oftentimes the best points of a book are what's included in magazine and newspaper articles and the frugal reader can save themselves the trouble and expense of reading the book and just read the articles. It's a little like reading the Cliff Notes and not the novel before book group....
That is not the case with this book which rambles far and wide into human decision making and focuses heavily on the biases of intuition. If you are a student of psychology, and to some degree we all are, or of economics or political science then I recommend it. Heck, if you like to play cards or gamble it's got some important points as well. Since anyone who makes decisions that aren't about things that are certain is "gambling" that expands the potential list of readership considerably.
Having pitched a 524 page book I'll offer up a short summary: Our brains have two modes of thinking and the one that springs to action most readily operates on a couple of simple principles. The first is What You See is All There Is and the second, loss is always to be avoided.
Most grown-ups know that those two axioms are not always true. Consider a shopping trip where the saleslady encourages you to try something on that you just know isn't "you" and lo and behold, it looks great. What I think I see on the hanger isn't what I see on me. For quick and dirty heuristics the rules aren't that bad. The authors like words like heuristics so be prepared if you decide to read the book.
Tidbits from the book that I found interesting:
• Pupil size is a proxy for interest and mental processing. I’ve resolved to remind myself to look at other people’s pupils when I’m talking so I can tell if they’re following me. Bigger is better. I do try to look people in the eye when talking with them but pupil size isn’t something that’s been on my radar.
• Humans have an innate bias against loss and it skews their perceptions of risk. The bias against loss is such that people will reject choices with likely opportunities for gain to avoid even small losses.
• With a clever set of experiments where subjects had their hands in icy cold water over differing temperatures/time periods they demonstrated how human memory of the pain/pleasure of events is biased. We remember the most intense moment of a good/bad experience and how it ended. The authors use the example of divorce. One could have been happily married for many years, but if the divorce is nasty and ends with the parties being unhappy the many happy years will get shorted when the marriage is remembered in the future.
• Decision-making is subject to anchoring from totally un-related elements. The authors flashed a number in front of subjects so quickly they hardly had time to recognize it. Later in a sequences of questions they asked questions about something very esoteric and the number the people had seen kept being answered back. Advertisers don't hesitate to manipulate consumers with this tactic. Consider a sale where everything is 25% off. Right off when you start shopping items with a price less than $25 will seem inexpensive because your brain has got the number 25 inserted into it.
• Most behaviors regress to a mean. This raises the question of whether praise for good behavior makes any difference because in all probability a good behavior/performance will be followed with a lesser one. One investing strategy, "Dogs of the Dow" has investors buy the lowest preforming stocks on the Dow Jones Indus trials at the beginning of the year, betting on them regressing towards the mean, which would be higher than their current "dog" status.
I was most interested in their work on intuition because I'm still appalled at the essay by Susan Sontag where she invokes a broad generality about women's intuition. We often hear about a "woman's intuition" as if this is something women that is innate and not learned. Susan Sontag, The Double Standard of Aging. Sontag, in her essay, describes how ... the wisdom considered the special province of women is “eternal,” an age-old, intuitive knowledge about the emotions to which a repertoire of facts, worldly experience, and the method of rational analysis have nothing to contribute, living long does not promise women an increase in wisdom either.
Thinking Fast and Slow authors discount the idea that intuition is known or predetermined. Kahneman quotes Herbert Simon on intuition: The situation has provided a cue, this cue has given the expert access to information stored in memory, and the information provides the answer. Intuition is nothing more and nothing less than recognition .
The authors lay out prerequisites for intuitive knowledge:
1) A regular environment/predictable
2) Opportunity for prolonged practice
They also state that intuition should not be trusted in the absence of a stable environment. Their work showing that we remember events by their maximum effect and ending is another reason that we should suspect intuitive judgements. The facts of the prior experience aren't always correct.
Returning to Sontag and her use of the concept of "eternal" knowledge. When my oldest was small I worked and they went to a babysitter, actually two women who watched children together. They were in their 60s, had raised their own children and kept other people's children for years. One summer after he turned 2 they announced I needed to bring a potty chair over because he was ready. I did so and before too long older son was in big boy pants during the day. Being sane we didn't try for dry at night for another year or two.
When my younger son was 2+ I decided I'd try potty training him. It was a messy disaster that generated untold loads of laundry.
The babysitters and I were both women, were some of us born with different knowledge than the other? I don't think so! Their prolonged practice at potty training children made the difference between a smooth mess-free transition and my experience.
I skewer Sontag for using the example about women's intuition as if she believed it. I don't believe that at all, she was bringing up the so-called wisdom of the day. If people, mostly men, think that women's intuition is something innate and not learned I would counter that their understanding of men appears that way because men are so predictable they are easy to learn. If you're looking for a heuristic how about, "the way to a man's heart is through his stomach?"
Back to Thinking. A huge divide among political groups centers around individual liberties and choices and those made for the collective. Those in favor of "free markets" and individual choice often claim that the best decisions are made when individuals make their own choices. I'm not going to say that I think that's not true, but after reading TFandS I have a more nuanced opinion. Our decision-making system(s) don't always provide us with the reliable facts, and are subject to internal and external manipulations.
So, a long read, but for me worth the time.
