Sunday was the day when we gathered to talk about "The Country Girls" by Edna O'Brien. After a suitable time for chit-chat we settled in and decided that although the book(s) were well written and the story engaging we didn't feel any sympathy for the characters or their sorry stories.
The first and second books ("The Country Girls" and "The Lonely Girl") are told from the perspective of the main character Kate. In the third book, "Girls in their Married Bliss" which covered their marital and adult relationship unhappiness, the narration flips around to a second character, Baba in several chapters making the story hard to follow.
We didn't relate to the heavy hand of the Catholic church in Ireland in the 1950s and the generally low expectations their families and society had for the girls. In the first book Kate, who comes from an indebted family with an alcoholic father, wins a scholarship to a catholic school. She attends with well to do friend Baba. All her efforts are directed at heading off Baba's telling everyone that she's the scholarship student from a poor family.
We felt a scholarship girl should have been proud to be smart and able to win a prize to go to a good school, not embarrassed that she wasn't paying to be there. Later Baba orchestras a prank that gets them both expelled. I think it all offended our motherly minds-- how could those girls be so stupid? Why didn't the nuns recognize that Kate was a smart girl and encourage her to stay away from Baba who wasn't a bit interested in school? They had low expectations for her as well.
There wasn't a decent man in the entire book. Alcoholic fathers, married men on the prowl for young girls, single men who live with their mothers. Did all the good men of Ireland leave?
So we made quick work of the book and sampled the dessert -
