Terri of RAGS Against the MACHINE recently mentioned an essay by Susan Sontag on the double standard for aging. It is a long essay of more than 5,000 words and focuses on why women experience discomfort with aging. I don’t really care for Sontag’s rambling organization or her tone, but she makes some observations that are interesting in the context of today’s political and economic issues.
Sontag begins her treatise by reviewing the typical reaction of women to the question, “how old are you? She explains that the question touches an electric rail, the
…ordeal of the imagination-a moral disease, a social pathology-intrinsic to which is the fact that it afflicts women much more than men. It is particularly women who experience growing older (everything that comes before one is actually oldGosh, and all this time I’d thought evasive answers to the “age” question were vanity.
It’s important to distinguish that Sontag is not talking about genuine old age. Sontag says ,
there..is no.. abnormality in the anguish and anger that people who are really old, in their seventies and eighties, feel about the implacable waning of their powers, physical and mental.
Having had the personal experiences of the passing of my in-laws and father I think it is important to note that genuine old-age and the indignities it brings does not have a double standard. It is for this reason that I propose to rename her essay – The Double Standard of the Middle-Aged Middle-Class.
She explains the double standard in terms of our capitalist consumption-oriented society. The social system that our capitalist system supports hangs shame and disgrace on those growing older because in a society, where the imagery designed to stimulate consumption, the most popular metaphor for happiness is “youth.” If we aren’t young anymore then we can’t be happy because we’re no longer in a state of desire, wanting, and endless acquisition. Give that many middle-aged women I know with children raised and mortgages under control have money to spend I don’t quite see why the society should discount women of a certain age, but that’s how Sontag puts it.
The middle-aged adrift are sandwiched in between the needy and growing younger generations and the government financed Medicare generation, which may well bankrupt our nation. Maybe our middle-aged woman will contribute with a minor case of breast cancer and can join the ranks of women fueling industrial America as they race, ever so incompetently, for a cure. .

In contrast, the middle-aged woman (who may also be the daughter of full-reimbursement Grandpa) is devalued in this consumption oriented scheme because she is beyond her reproductive years and can no longer produce new little consumers, but isn’t yet supplying the Medicare gravy-train to corporate America. If she’s lower class and unemployed she can prove her worth by caring for Grandkids, if not she’s left to sink in her purgatory, until she hits to golden qualification age. Sontag notes that
…nothing so clearly indicates the fictional nature of this crisis than the fact that women who keep their youthful appearance the longest –women who lead un strenuous, physically sheltered lives, who eat balanced meals, who can afford good medical care, who have few or no children – are those feel the defeat of age most keenly.
Past 35, no children to occupy your time? Twiddle your thumbs while you grow old, or get a job!
Middle-aged men, particularly if they’re financially successful, fare better in these years not only because of their reproductive potential but also because of their life-long dominant position. Sontag notes that men are not judged as harshly because the value of their existence does not diminish with age:
“Masculinity” is identified with competence, autonomy, self-control-qualities which the disappearance of youth does not threaten. Competence in most of the activities expected from men… increases with age. ..Because the wisdom considered the special province of women is “eternal”, and age-old, intuitive knowledge and the emotions to which a repertoire of fact, worldly experience, and the method of rational analysis have nothing to contribute, living long does not promise women an increase in wisdom. ”Femininity” is identified with incompetence, helplessness, passivity, non-competitiveness and being nice. Age does not improve these qualities.
I’d never considered that “women’s intuition” was a construct to devalue the intelligence of women as a group. A women’s utility is predestined, much like she’s born with finite eggs in her ovaries.
The essay was a heavy load to read and digest. Most of the 5,000 words are devoted to describing women’s middle-aged life in downtrodden terms - not a mood lifter!
Later that weekend while reading the Sunday paper I happened upon an article , Get a Midlife. This article, begins by explaining that when people over 65 are asked what age they’d like to return to they don’t pick their youth, they pick their 40s. Measures of happiness and well-being identified that feelings of personal growth, autonomy, supportive social relationships, self-regard, and a sense of purpose were higher in the mid-life group, and contributed to their happiness and well-being. These elements are not so different from Sontag’s masculine qualities that the disappearance of youth does not threaten.
The article noted that middle-aged women are more likely to suffer from depression, a money-making condition for drug companies who've trained all their doctors to write a script, but are also likely to report higher scores for these happiness parameters (it’s not clear this held true at the respondent level or at the aggregate level). That paradoxical finding left me humming the Girl Scout song, if you’re happy and you know it stomp your feet….
In conclusion Sontag, predictably, urges women to
aspire to be wise, not merely nice; to be competent, not merely helpful; to be strong, not merely graceful; to be ambitions for themselves, not merely for themselves in relation to men and children. …Instead of being girls, girls as long as possible, ..they can become women much earlier and remain active adults.
Reading her words and considering what's happened since 1979, the year I graduated from college, I think of Rahm Emanuel. The quote often attributed to him, you never want a serious crisis to go to waste, seems like a good description of the expansion of women’s roles in the American economy over the past 40 years.
Middle class women were pushed into the work force beginning in the 1970s. As younger women matured they began to expect to enter the workforce, and oriented their educational years towards workforce participation. Women made some strides, breaking out of their traditional occupations and gaining ground against inequality in the workplace - although there is still room for progress.
I believe that participating in the workforce economy along with changes in societal norms and pushes for gender equality have reshaped the American world so that middle class girls grow into women expecting to be valued for their abilities and capacities beyond merely their roles as wives and mothers.
Middle class women were pushed into the work force beginning in the 1970s. As younger women matured they began to expect to enter the workforce, and oriented their educational years towards workforce participation. Women made some strides, breaking out of their traditional occupations and gaining ground against inequality in the workplace - although there is still room for progress.
I believe that participating in the workforce economy along with changes in societal norms and pushes for gender equality have reshaped the American world so that middle class girls grow into women expecting to be valued for their abilities and capacities beyond merely their roles as wives and mothers.
I think that the clearest signal that the world Sontag describes has changed is shown by her statements about women, conservatism and their bodies:
Women care for their bodies-against toughening, coarsening, getting fat. They conserve them. (Perhaps the fact that women in modern societies tend to have a more conservative political outlook than men originates in their profoundly conservative relation to their bodies.)
Not any more! In 2009 the Gallup poll organization found that women are more likely than men to be Democratic, they’re also more likely than men to be ideologically “moderate” and “liberal” and less likely to be “conservative,” I think that with the rise of single parent households, divorce and unemployment that women, not grown-up girls, have taken on more responsibility for the well-being of their families and themselves, and rather than embracing established hierarchies are looking for support in maintaining themselves and their families.
The sterotypes of aging women that Sontag describes have not changed in the years since the publication of her essay, but society and women's roles have expanded. Isn't it said that a woman's work is never done? It may well be that when a woman hedges on her age or dyes her hair in today’s society that it’s not vanity or shame, but an competitive un-feminine desire to make sure that she maintains her place in the dominant culture and that it doesn’t have a chance to pass her by.









































